SQE2

Case and Matter Analysis in SQE2: Turning FLK1 Law Into Advice

CELE SQE Team
·
·
4 views
·
10 min read

Este artigo ainda não está disponível no seu idioma — exibindo a edição em inglês.

Case and Matter Analysis in SQE2: Turning FLK1 Law Into Advice
Learn how to structure SQE2 Case and Matter Analysis answers: spot issues, apply FLK1 law, weigh options and give clear next steps your client can act on.

The file is open on your screen. It holds an attendance note, three emails, a two-page contract and a short memo from a partner. At the bottom is the task: "Prepare a report advising on the client's position and recommending next steps." You know the law. You passed SQE1. So why does the cursor sit blinking for five minutes while you wonder where to begin?

That freeze is very common in SQE2 Case and Matter Analysis. In SQE1 the question was already framed for you. Now you have to find the questions yourself, and then answer them in a way a busy partner, and in the end a client, can act on. This article shows you how to make that jump. It uses a worked example drawn from FLK1 law, because that is where many candidates find the gap between knowing the law and advising on it widest.

What SQE2 Case and Matter Analysis Actually Tests

Case and Matter Analysis is one of the five SQE2 skills, alongside Client Interviewing, Advocacy, Legal Research and Legal Writing/Drafting. It is a written task. You receive case materials and produce a written analysis, usually framed as a report to a supervising solicitor. You type your answer on the Pearson VUE closed platform. There is no internet and no spellchecker to save you.

Under the latest SRA specification, the marking looks at two broad things. One is the skill: identifying the relevant facts, spotting the issues, weighing the options and giving clear, client-focused advice. The other is the application of law: whether your legal analysis is correct, comprehensive and relevant to the facts. Both count. A beautifully organised report built on the wrong legal test will not pass. Neither will a correct statement of the law that never touches the client's actual problem.

The examiner is not asking, "Does this candidate know contract law?" The examiner is asking, "Would I be comfortable sending this to a client after a light edit?"

Keep that second question in mind. It changes how you write.

Reading the File: An Issue-Spotting Routine for SQE2

Most weak scripts fail before a single word is typed. The candidate skims the file, spots the obvious issue and starts writing. Twenty minutes later they find the email that changes everything.

I tell my students to read the file twice, and to do something different each time.

First read: the task and the client. Start with the instruction from the partner, not the evidence. What exactly are you asked to do? Advise on liability? Recommend a strategy? Who is the client, and what do they want? A client who wants to keep a valuable supplier relationship needs different advice from one who wants to recover every penny.

Second read: facts with legal weight. Now go through the documents slowly. Note every date, figure, signature, missing signature and inconsistency. Dates are the classic trap, because they drive limitation, notice periods and deadlines. Write a short timeline on your scratch notes before you write anything else.

As you read, sort what you find into three lists:

  • Legal issues – the claims, defences and procedural points.
  • Evidential gaps – facts you need but do not yet have.
  • Ethical or professional points – conflicts, confidentiality, client instructions you cannot follow.

That third list matters. Ethics is pervasive in the SQE, and the case materials often hide a professional conduct issue in plain sight. Candidates focused on the black-letter law miss it again and again.

Applying FLK1 Law: A Worked Case and Matter Analysis Example

Let us make this concrete. Here is a simplified version of the sort of file you might see.

Harbour Fabrication Ltd bought a cutting machine from Delta Tools Ltd for £48,000. The machine broke down repeatedly in its first month. As a result, Harbour missed delivery on an unusually profitable contract with a new customer and lost £90,000 of profit. Delta's standard terms limit its liability "for any defect" to the purchase price. The machine was delivered eleven months ago. Harbour's managing director emails you: "Can we just say we told Delta about the big contract? Nobody can prove we didn't."

How would you break this down? Here is the analysis I would expect from a strong candidate.

Issue 1: Breach of contract

This is a business-to-business sale of goods, so the Sale of Goods Act 1979 applies, not the Consumer Rights Act 2015. Section 14(2) implies a term that goods sold in the course of a business are of satisfactory quality. Repeated breakdowns in the first month of use point strongly to breach. Do not stop at "there is a breach". Tie it to the evidence: which documents show the breakdowns, and will Harbour need an engineer's report?

Issue 2: The limitation clause

Delta will rely on its clause capping liability at the price. Under the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, section 6(1A), liability for breach of the implied terms in section 14 of the 1979 Act can be excluded or restricted against a non-consumer only if the term satisfies the requirement of reasonableness. The test sits in section 11, with the guidelines in Schedule 2 relevant here: the parties' relative bargaining strength, whether Harbour could have bought elsewhere without the term, and whether it knew of the term. A good answer applies those factors to the facts and explains what further information you need, such as whether Harbour negotiated the terms.

Issue 3: Remoteness of the lost profit

This is where the money is, and where the case may turn. Under Hadley v Baxendale (1854), losses are recoverable if they arise naturally from the breach, or if they were in the reasonable contemplation of both parties when the contract was made. Victoria Laundry (Windsor) Ltd v Newman Industries Ltd [1949] draws the key distinction: ordinary lost profits may be recoverable, but profits from exceptionally lucrative contracts are not, unless the defendant knew about them. Harbour's lost contract was "unusually profitable". So the realistic advice is that ordinary profit is arguable, while the exceptional part is at serious risk.

Issue 4: The ethical problem

The managing director's email is a trap, and a deliberate one. You must not mislead the court or others, and you must not help a client put forward evidence you know to be false. The SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors is clear on this. Your report should say plainly that the firm cannot advance that assertion. It should also explain to the client, in a constructive tone, why a false account would damage both credibility and the claim.

Issue 5: Time and procedure

Under section 5 of the Limitation Act 1980, a claim in simple contract must be brought within six years of the cause of action accruing. That is no immediate concern here, and saying so in one line shows good judgement. Before any claim is issued, the parties should comply with the Practice Direction on Pre-Action Conduct and Protocols. That means a clear letter of claim, a reasonable response period and some consideration of ADR.

Options, Risks and Next Steps: What SQE2 Examiners Want

Plenty of candidates analyse the law well and then stop. That is a mistake. Case and Matter Analysis is about the matter, and a matter needs a plan.

For Harbour, a strong report sets out the realistic options side by side:

  • Negotiate – use the reasonableness argument as leverage to settle above the purchase price, which would also protect the supplier relationship if that matters to the client.
  • Issue proceedings – a stronger position, but with costs risk, delay and a real chance that the exceptional profit is held too remote.
  • ADR – mediation may suit two trading companies, and courts expect it to be considered.

Then commit to a recommendation. Hedging everything ("it depends") reads as a lack of judgement. You can be honest about uncertainty and still say, "On balance, I recommend a letter of claim seeking the ordinary lost profit and the cost of repair, while inviting mediation."

Finish with concrete next steps. Who does what, and by when? Obtain an engineer's report. Preserve all maintenance logs and emails. Confirm what Delta was told before the contract was signed. Check whether Harbour signed the standard terms. These small, practical actions are what separate a pass from a comfortable pass.

A useful test: could the client read your final section on its own and know exactly what happens next? If not, rewrite it.

Common Case and Matter Analysis Mistakes in SQE2

After marking a great many practice scripts, I see the same problems again and again.

Writing a textbook. Two paragraphs on the history of remoteness earns nothing. State the test in one or two sentences, then spend your words on the facts.

Ignoring the client's goals. If the file says the client values the relationship, your advice should reflect that. Generic advice looks like it was written without reading the file.

Missing the ethics point. If something in the file makes you slightly uneasy, there is probably a conduct issue. Deal with it directly.

No structure. Use short headings in your answer: Summary, Issues, Analysis, Options, Recommendation, Next Steps. The marker should be able to find everything in seconds.

Running out of time. A brilliant analysis of two issues with no recommendation scores worse than a solid treatment of all five. Plan your time before you start, and leave room for the advice section.

A Practical Plan to Prepare for SQE2 Case and Matter Analysis

So what should you actually do over the next few weeks?

Refresh the law in the SQE2 practice areas. SQE2 written tasks draw on practice contexts such as dispute resolution, criminal litigation, property practice, wills and intestacy, probate practice, and business organisations. Much of this overlaps with your FLK1 and FLK2 knowledge. Revise the tests you will apply, not every detail.

Build a fixed answer template. Decide your headings now so you never waste exam time on structure. A one-line executive summary at the top is a good habit, because partners and clients read it first.

Practise under real conditions. Type your answers in a plain text editor, with no spellcheck and a strict timer. The closed platform feels very different from your usual word processor, and you should get used to it early.

Review against the criteria, not your memory. After each attempt, check three things. Did you spot every issue? Was each legal test correct? Did you give a clear recommendation and next steps? Keep a log of what you missed. Patterns appear quickly.

Read your answer as the client. Strip out jargon where you can. "The clause may not be enforceable because it may be unreasonable" is clearer than a paragraph of statutory language with no conclusion.

None of this is glamorous. But Case and Matter Analysis rewards habit far more than talent. Candidates who follow the same disciplined routine on every file tend to improve steadily, and they rarely freeze in front of a blank screen.

How CELE SQE Can Help

If you would like structured practice, the CELE SQE SQE2 Course (£1,450) includes 61 full mock questions built 1:1 to the official SRA format, with Case and Matter Analysis tasks that follow the routine described above. If you are still working towards SQE1, our full SQE1 courses start at £1,750 for the Short-term Course, and a single FLK costs 60% of the relevant course price. You can find details at celebar.com, or contact us on WeChat SQE100 or at [email protected] with any questions.

Compartilhar este artigo

Artigos relacionados

Todos os artigos