SQE1

Criminal Law and Practice SQE1 FLK2: Police Station Advice and PACE

CELE SQE Team
·
·
0 views
·
9 min read
Criminal Law and Practice SQE1 FLK2: Police Station Advice and PACE
Master police station advice for SQE1 FLK2 Criminal Law and Practice: detention limits, the right to silence, adverse inferences and PACE exclusion rules.

It is 2am. Your client has been arrested on suspicion of burglary. He is tired and frightened, and he wants to "just explain everything" to the officers. The custody sergeant says interview is in forty minutes. The disclosure officer has given you two lines. What do you tell him?

This scene sits at the centre of Criminal Law and Practice in SQE1 FLK2. Many candidates know the rules in the abstract and then lose marks under exam pressure. The questions are rarely about reciting a section number. They test whether you can apply PACE and the adverse inference rules to a specific client, in a specific room, at a specific moment. This guide covers the police station stage in that practical way.

Why Police Station Advice Matters in SQE1 FLK2

From the January 2027 sitting, SQE1 questions are grouped by session. Criminal Law and Practice sits in FLK2 Session 2, alongside Property Law and Practice, Solicitors Accounts and Criminal Liability. That session is 85 Single Best Answer questions in 2 hours 33 minutes, so you have roughly 1.8 minutes per question. Ethics remains pervasive across the paper, which matters a lot here. The police station is where professional conduct and criminal procedure collide most often.

In my experience, candidates who struggle with this area are not short of knowledge. They answer the question they expected rather than the one in front of them. A stem about an 18-year-old is not a stem about a juvenile. A stem with no legal advice is not a stem where inferences can be drawn. Small facts carry the whole answer.

PACE 1984 Detention Rules for SQE1 Criminal Practice

The Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (PACE) and its Codes of Practice govern what happens after arrest. Code C deals with detention, treatment and questioning. Code D deals with identification. Code E covers the audio recording of interviews.

The detention clock

The basic limit is 24 hours from the "relevant time", which is usually arrival at the police station. Under s.42 PACE, an officer of at least superintendent rank may extend this to 36 hours if the offence is indictable and the other statutory conditions are met. Beyond 36 hours, the police must apply to a magistrates' court for a warrant of further detention. The overall maximum, for most offences, is 96 hours.

Reviews of detention are a common trap. The first review must take place no later than 6 hours after detention was first authorised. Later reviews must take place at intervals of no more than 9 hours. For a suspect who has not been charged, the review officer must be at least the rank of inspector.

Exam tip: when a question gives you times, draw a quick timeline on your whiteboard. Mark arrival, authorisation of detention and each review. Most timing questions become simple arithmetic once the facts are laid out.

The right to legal advice

Under s.58 PACE, a detained person is entitled to consult a solicitor privately at any time. The advice is free. Delay is allowed only in limited cases: the offence must be indictable, an officer of at least superintendent rank must authorise it, and there must be reasonable grounds to believe that access would lead to specified harms, such as interference with evidence or alerting other suspects. The maximum delay is 36 hours from the relevant time.

Remember the vulnerable suspect. A juvenile (under 18) or a vulnerable adult must have an appropriate adult. The appropriate adult is not a lawyer. Conversations with them are not covered by legal professional privilege, which is why a solicitor will usually want a private consultation with the client alone.

The Right to Silence and Adverse Inferences in Criminal Law and Practice

Back to the 2am client. Should he answer questions, stay silent, or give a prepared statement? This is the most tested advice decision in the area, and it rests on the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994.

Section 34: failure to mention facts

A court or jury may draw a "proper" inference where the defendant, when questioned under caution or on charge, failed to mention a fact later relied on in their defence. The fact must be one the defendant could reasonably have been expected to mention at the time. R v Argent [1997] sets out the conditions, and the court asks what was reasonable for this particular defendant, in these particular circumstances.

Two points regularly decide exam answers:

  • Under s.34(2A), no inference can be drawn at a police station if the suspect was not allowed an opportunity to consult a solicitor before questioning.
  • Silence on legal advice does not automatically protect the client. The jury may still draw an inference if it concludes the client stayed silent because they had no answer that would stand up to scrutiny, rather than because they genuinely and reasonably relied on the advice (R v Beckles [2004]).

Sections 36 and 37: objects, marks and presence

Section 36 covers a failure to account for objects, substances or marks on the person, their clothing or in the place of arrest. Section 37 covers a failure to account for presence at a place at or about the time of the offence. Both require a "special warning" in ordinary language. If the special warning was not given, no inference can follow. That single missing fact can turn a question around.

One further rule underpins all of this. Under s.38(3), a person cannot be convicted solely on an inference drawn from silence. There must be other evidence.

Choosing the advice

Silence is often appropriate where police disclosure is minimal, where the client is unfit or highly distressed, or where the legal position is complex. Answering questions may suit a client with a clear, credible account, such as an alibi that can be checked quickly. A prepared statement, followed by a "no comment" interview, is a middle path. It sets out the key facts of the defence now, which reduces the risk of a s.34 inference, without exposing the client to cross-examination by the officers.

The weakness of a prepared statement is simple. If the defence at trial departs from it, the inference risk returns. So the statement must be accurate and complete on the essential facts.

Professional Conduct at the Police Station: SQE1 Ethics Traps

Ethics questions here look like procedure questions. Read them twice.

Suppose your client privately admits the burglary, but wants to deny it in interview. You may still advise silence. You may continue to act and put the prosecution to proof. What you must not do is help the client put forward a positive account you know to be false. That would breach your duty not to mislead the court or others, and your duty to uphold the rule of law and the proper administration of justice. If the client insists on lying, you must decline to act further.

Conflicts of interest are the other big theme. Two co-suspects arrested for the same incident may seem easy to advise together. But if their accounts differ, or one may blame the other, you cannot act for both. Take instructions from each separately before deciding, and keep confidential information protected throughout.

Ask yourself two questions in any police station ethics stem: "Would this mislead anyone?" and "Am I still acting in this client's best interests, given who else I represent?" Those two questions eliminate most wrong options.

Identification and Excluding Evidence in FLK2 Criminal Practice

The police station stage does not end with interview. Identification procedures under Code D are also tested. Where identification is disputed and an eyewitness may be able to identify the suspect, the police should generally hold an identification procedure, usually a video identification. If they fail to do so, the defence has grounds to challenge the evidence.

At trial, two PACE provisions do most of the work:

  • Section 76 concerns confessions. If a confession was, or may have been, obtained by oppression, or in circumstances likely to make it unreliable, the court must exclude it unless the prosecution proves beyond reasonable doubt that it was not so obtained. Exclusion is mandatory once that test is met.
  • Section 78 is a general discretion. The court may exclude any prosecution evidence if admitting it would have such an adverse effect on the fairness of proceedings that it ought not to be admitted. Significant and substantial breaches of the Codes often lead here.

Where a disputed identification goes before a jury, the judge should give a R v Turnbull [1977] direction. This warns the jury of the special need for caution and asks them to consider the circumstances of the identification, such as distance, lighting, duration and whether the witness knew the suspect.

In the exam, distinguish carefully. Is the evidence a confession? Then start with s.76, and treat s.78 as a fallback. Is it any other evidence, such as an identification? Then s.78 is your route.

How to Revise Police Station Law for SQE1 FLK2

Reading is not enough for this topic. You need to practise decisions. Here is what I suggest to my own students:

  • Build one master timeline. Put arrest, relevant time, reviews, the 24-hour, 36-hour and 96-hour limits, and the delay to legal advice on a single page. Redraw it from memory each week.
  • Make an inference checklist. For each of s.34, s.36 and s.37, list the conditions. Was there a caution? A special warning? An opportunity to consult a solicitor? Is there other evidence?
  • Write three short client scenarios. One where silence is best, one where answering is best, one where a prepared statement is best. Explain your reasons in two sentences each.
  • Practise timed SBA questions. Aim for about 1.8 minutes each. When you get one wrong, record which fact you missed, not just the rule.

Why focus on the missed fact? Because in this area the rule is rarely the problem. The age of the suspect, the rank of the officer or the absence of a special warning is what changes the answer. Training your eye for those details is the skill FLK2 rewards.

How CELE SQE Can Help

At CELE SQE we teach Criminal Law and Practice through realistic, exam-style scenarios like the one above, so the rules become decisions you can make quickly. Our full SQE1 courses cover FLK1 and FLK2: Long-term £3,720, Mid-term £2,750 or Short-term £1,750. If you only need FLK2, a single FLK is 60% of the course price (Long-term £2,232, Mid-term £1,650, Short-term £1,050), and the SQE1 Question Bank is £575 per month, or £287.50 per month for FLK2 only. You can find details at celebar.com, email [email protected] or contact us on WeChat at SQE100.

Share this article

Related articles

All articles